Four Stories (Sheila Watson)

Sheila Watson is best known as the author of the Canadian classic The Double Hook — one of the few “Canadian classics” that is not a chore to read. Watson only ever published two novels and five short stories … these are four. I have a copy of the original Coach House publication (Coach House PRESS, for the geeks), a library discard. The stories all concern characters with names from Greek myths who live and are anxious in a surreal non-world that is supposedly Canada.

There is a brilliant strangeness to the movement of the stories, especially evident in the dialogue. This from “Brother Oedipus”:

‘While you care for the roses and stand about under the willow,' [Oedipus's wife — who's not his mother in the story] said, ‘I must care for both of us. You promised to take out the garbage.'

‘I have lost interest in ash cans and their contents,' said Oedipus. ‘But the cats which come to the cans are a different matter.'

The stories are unlike anything I've ever seen. They are at turns surreal and poetic, fable-like, and even banal. In “The Black Farm,” Daedalus is a businessman who becomes obsessed with creating an utterly black farm so that he might, enrobed in gold, stand in stark contrast to the farm. But he can't quite get the total black he desires and so resorts to magic (black magic, of course), and fails. The story ends, like all the stories, in an abrupt and brutal fashion. Watson almost seems to cut her stories to an end with a very sharp knife, and it's devastating.

Watson's beginnings are no less fascinating. I'm utterly transfixed by her ability to develop a story that has almost no stability as if she were developing any regular old story. Here's the opening of “The Rumble Seat”:

Oedipus folded his legs. It was a sad story. He had adjusted himself as the cameras circled. We could not see them but we knew they were there. Information is no longer the prerogative of the few. Besides Oedipus was pointing above him now to something which was excluded from our television screen.

Later in the story Oedipus ponders his namesake myth. His interviewer states “We must … demythologize” and Oedipus replies:

For me it is too late … although since some Protestantism has not yet fully acknowledged Freud there might still be time. For some I have already become a complex, for others a thematic design like the sphere, the cylinder, and the cube.

Watson's stories are stunning and singular and possessed of an insane, twisting energy. I'll be reading her other books as soon as I find them.

— Jonathan Ball

Liked it? Take a second to support Jonathan Ball on Patreon!

Jonathan Ball is a writer, filmmaker, and scholar living at

Liked it? Take a second to support Jonathan Ball on Patreon!
I want to send you my best new work.

I want to send you my best new work.

Every week, I will send you my best new page, and tell you about how I wrote it. I'll share resources I used, techniques you could try, and other behind-the-scenes information and writing advice.

Liked it? Take a second to support Jonathan Ball on Patreon!

4 thoughts on “Four Stories (Sheila Watson)

  1. hey JB;
    watson’s DOUBLE HOOK blew me away when i first read it, and its still incredible (esp for its date, 1959) … not much out there by her: FOUR STORIES (1979) and her 1984 CHP reissue as FIVE STORIES and then the 1992 edition of DEEP HOLLOW CREEK; thats it. all of her criticism (and the whole of FOUR STORIES) is gatherED in OPEN LETTER 3.1… as far as i know thats everything she published….
    rock on

  2. Thanks derek — I knew about all the books but wasn’t aware of the Open Letter issue with her criticism — will have to check that out. I have a copy of DEEP HOLLOW CREEK that I have been meaning to read, and will do so soon.

  3. continuing the bibliographical trend:

    just heard that Watson had a new collection of her short fiction entitled A FATHER’S KINGDOM published a few years back (how did i not know!?) which contains all of her short stories from 5 STORIES as well as a recently discovered 6th!… the new issue of PRECIPICe also includes a selection of previously unpublished Watson poems…

  4. Somebody should edit a Watson collected. If I wasn’t overcommitted right now already, I would try to do it myself. Will be curious to check out those poems.

Join the Conversation!

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.